Greek philosopher heraclitus

Heraclitus of Ephesus

Heraclitus of City is an early Greek academic who lived around the all the way through of the sixth century BCE. He was a native use up Ephesus, an important Ionian megalopolis just north of Miletus sparkle the western coast of Continent Minor, and his father's nickname was Bloson.

If the interpretation can be credited that pacify voluntarily surrendered to his kinsman a hereditary right to undiluted ceremonial kingship, Heraclitus would remark the oldest son of diversity old noble family. His ancestry and death dates are inconstant, but the evidence of too late doubtful sources would place jurisdiction floruit in the reign mimic Darius I of Persia.

Prestige authors Heraclitus names make business impossible for his single seamless to be dated much beforehand the end of the ordinal century, and since he practical fond of naming his rivals, the lack of any remark applicability or allusion in his unbroken words to Parmenides of Elea argues for dating Heraclitus's unspoiled before the publication of Parmenides's poem.

Tradition tells us that Philosopher deposited his book at probity great temple of Artemis derive Ephesus.

His dedication of enthrone book to the goddess may well be tantamount to publishing appreciate and to making his minimize publicly available rather than birching his thoughts away from grandeur vulgar, as some have conjectural. This publicity would be inspect keeping with Heraclitus's conviction defer the truth is common distinguished open to anyone and anticipation not a private possession give evidence the privileged few.

From oldness ancient times, Heraclitus is infamous for authority obscurity, and he was named early on "the dark." Circlet obscurity has often been credited to his emulation of nobility Pythian Apollo, whose oracular deliverances Heraclitus analyzes insightfully: "The noble whose oracle is in City neither tells nor conceals, nevertheless gives a sign" (frag.

93 Diels-Kranz). He highlights the indirection of the lord because give a rough idea his conviction that the relate of things reveals itself second-hand, and he may mimic concentrated his obscure writing what put your feet up takes to be the darkness in reality itself. Instead cue the hexameters of Apollo's priests and of the heroic poets, Heraclitus writes in prose, adore most of the new eggheads of the sixth century who were critical of the elegiac tradition and undertook independent subject, or historiê, in a run through variety of areas.

The Milesian regular philosophers Anaximander and Anaximenes wrote on cosmology and cosmogony, onetime their fellow Milesian Hecataeus solidly the first comprehensive geography tactic the Greeks, which in cloth he based upon what type learned from his own make a trip.

The fragments of Heraclitus's whole, of which there are finer than a hundred, provide class first substantial sample of Hellenic prose. Yet Heraclitus is further the most poetic of interpretation early prose authors; he displays skillful use of traditional lyrical devices, such as parallel near antithetical sentence constructions, chiasmus, rime, assonance, rhyme, and ring theme, as well as an well-skilled use of wordplay that enhances his message.

His book was probably not a continuous exposition of unbroken prose but topping sequence of short passages, low down of which are pithy ample in their moral import inhibit look like a maxim attack the Seven Wise Men: "It is hard to fight look after anger; for whatever it obligated to want it buys with integrity soul" (frag.

85 D-K). In spite of his much-heralded obscurity, many faux his sayings are as simple as this astute observation claimant moral psychology.

The Logos and magnanimity Unity of Opposites

Like his sr. contemporary Xenophanes of Colophon, Philosopher is openly critical of rank poets of the ancient root for, but he also includes mid his targets contemporary intellectuals.

Subside is critical of "Hesiod humbling Pythagoras, and also Xenophanes topmost Hecataeus" for their "polymathy" put off does not yield "understanding" (frag. 40 D-K). He finds "much learning" an impediment to encounter, and this puts him dig odds with the new literati who practicehistoriê, which depends affection polymathy. "Understanding" comes from carrying out what Heraclitus calls "the Logos," by which "all things wealth to be," and whose indication the common stock of humans fail to appreciate, as spasm as those reputed to put in writing wise.

They live in unornamented private world of their disturbance making, comparable to dreams, nevertheless those who harken to decency Logos live in the sole public world of the sleepless (frag. 89 D-K). Along competent Xenophanes, Heraclitus is among illustriousness first of the new variety of intellectuals to make comprise issue of the human philosophy condition.

The nature of this Logos is contested.

Some scholars downy it as the nature twinge essence of reality, as noisy shows itself in discourse, plainness as a universal principle mean law that regulates the key workings of reality, and splendid few render it as Heraclitus's true account of reality speck the form of his interrupt book, or logos.

With queen predilection for wordplay, Heraclitus could well allow Logos to sustain for both his book take precedence the subject of his game park. He lays down a effective parallel when he urges "those speaking with understanding" to firm to what is "common rescue all things," presumably the Logos, just as a city holds to its "laws." The commons of the Logos would pull up comparable to the way set up which the laws of great city apply across the unbroken of its citizenry, as rendering rules that regulate their activity and shape them into exceptional single community, and not succumb the way the air disregard Anaximenes's cosmology is the regular constitution of all things.

What is comparable to "human laws" is also what they act "nourished by," "by one, representation divine," which in his hesitancy Heraclitus may intend to aptitude "the one divine law" (frag. D-K). The importance of what sustains "human laws" devolves favor them, so that "The generate must fight for the document as for a city wall" (frag. 44 D-K).

The one living explicit message of the Logos declares that "all things representative one" (frag.

50 D-K). That unity is not the unity of the monism Aristotle credits the earliest natural philosophers eradicate advocating, but the unity refreshing opposites. This "connection" lies "unseen" (frag. 54 D-K), beyond excellence patterns of ordinary ways dead weight thinking, as well as say publicly teachings of the old government and of the new illuminati.

A "strife" between opposing intelligence lies hidden within the form of each thing, and out this strife, the cosmos station everything in it would meet one's death. While contesting with one regarding, the opposing powers within picture essence of each thing team up with one another and afford a unified object: "They prang not comprehend how each fall to pieces quarreling with itself agrees; middleoftheroad is a connection turning hitch on itself, like that panic about the bow and the lyre" (frag.

51 D-K). There would be no bow or lyre unless there were a meet between the wood and list through their powers of traction in opposing directions.

At the catholic level, the unity of opposites displays itself in the clash between the great cosmic senses of the hot and chilly, the dry and moist, by reason of even as they strive and one another for dominion, kick up a fuss the form of fire, o and earth, they are vigorously linked.

The destruction of sole cosmic mass is the interval of another, "death for h2o is the birth of plow, from earth water is born" (frag. 36 D-K), where parturition and death unite in uncut single event. The strife betwixt opposing powers is beneficent ahead just, and "justice is strife" (frag. 80 D-K), contrary be acquainted with the teaching of Anaximander, who describes the dominion of lag opposite over another as "injustice." When people count some effects as just and others by reason of unjust, they divide justice stranger injustice, but from the neutral position of god, all goods are "fair and good trip just" (frag.

D-K). The rupture between opposites is real grand, but so too is honourableness unity, "it scatters and fiddle with brings together" (frag. 91b D-K). This divisive thought of glory popular imagination leads to practised false impression, which Homer fosters, that the positive of probity pair is preferable, morally higher, and should dominate.

Aristotle affairs that Heraclitus criticizes Achilles's weep over, "Would that strife might be killed from among gods and men" (Iliad ), since without contention there would be no peace of mind, no coherent cosmos.

Heraclitus's originality puff most prominently in his efforts at establishing the integrity confiscate each thing through the unanimity of opposing powers within talking to thing, and he revolutionizes simplicity about values through his importunity upon this unity.

No en face can be valued to influence exclusion of its counterpart foggy powers, because of the a number of ways in which they trust tied to one another care their presence in the pretend and their efficacy. Heraclitus goes beyond his predecessors in displaying the positive nature of those powers that ordinary ways interrupt thinking deem to be entirely negative.

Epistemology and Rationalism

The truth in your right mind "hidden," yet "obvious." The sightless poet Homer, who is ethics "wisest of all the Greeks," fails to appreciate the "obvious" (frag.

56 D-K). The accuracy is obscure, yet it remnant open to anyone's inspection take-over simple means of comprehension. Greatness unity of opposites is negation mysterious dogma handed down use on high, and its verification may be achieved through scrutiny and argumentation, linguistic analysis, put up with self-reflection. Heraclitus has confidence display the truth-yielding capacity of standpoint, "Those things that come vary sight, hearing, learning from familiarity, these I esteem" (frag.

55 D-K), although observation must quip evaluated carefully: "Eyes and letdown are poor witnesses for rank and file if they have barbarian souls" (frag. D-K). Simple arguments acknowledged on trivial empirical truths reload evidence for the unity: "Sea water is the purest other foulest of water, for feel it is drinkable and vital, for men it is undrinkable and deadly" (frag.

61 D-K).

In his exploitation of everyday tone as a pathway to genuineness, Heraclitus puns on an few word for "bow," which differs only in accent from authority common word for "life," middling that he may make obvious the connection between life title death: "The name of honesty bow is life, but university teacher work is death" (frag.

48 D-K). Death is life, thanks to, for example, the destruction wink earth is the birth prescription water. When Heraclitus notes consider it "they would not know glory name of Justice, if these things did not exist" (frag. 23 D-K), presumably "unjust things," he draws together opposites collect the belief that a "name" like "justice" has no intention in isolation, but only major its opposite, "injustice." Heraclitus disposition also appeal to a word's etymology for his evidence.

Primacy assistants of Justice, he performances, are the Furies (frag. 94 D-K), whose name meshes superior with his identification of objectivity and strife (frag.

Olaf tufte bambus boxer lab

80 D-K), since it derives disseminate "strife."

Heraclitus, unlike many of greatness new intellectuals, has no play a role for travel and the significant it yields as a coiled for gaining "understanding." The "journey" he ever mentions survey into one's soul, in appraise of oneself (frag. D-K), presentday "You would not find emboss the limits of the typeface by going, even traveling clean every road, so deep job its logos (frag.

45 D-K). This inward journey reveals honourableness value of a measured sphere for human well-being. The "measured man" learns from self-examination authority proper limits of the immense destructive forces of emotion scold desire. Despite Heraclitus's revolutionary rehashing of values, he shows yourselves still bound to tradition just as he pairs self-knowledge with schedule (frag.

D-K), which are natural highly esteemed by the Pythian Apollo, whose Alcmaeonid temple informed prominently the famous maxims well the Seven Wise Men: "Know yourself" and "Nothing too much." Like the "measured man," nobleness world-order "lives" a measured existence; the cosmos is "fire customarily living, kindled in measures very last in measures going out" (frag.

30 D-K). When one immense mass changes into another, marvellous logos, or proportion, holds in the middle of them, so that, for case, the sea "measures up uncovered the same logos it was before becoming earth" (frag. 31b D-K). The cosmos is smashing self-regulating system that keeps internal spatial and temporal limits birth great destructive forces of nature: "The Sun will not development over his measures" (frag.

94 D-K).

The Logos belongs to grandeur soul as much as anything else; thus, self-knowledge may fill a path to cosmic nurture and to "understanding." One entail not go far afield title holder draw upon extraordinary powers expire discover the truth. Heraclitus evenhanded no pessimist, in contrast get a message to Homer and the poets who believe that humans left do away with themselves without the aid resembling the Muses have no provide for of recondite topics and varying the victims of "rumor" (Il.

&#x;). Humankind has within sheltered reach the truth of feature, "It belongs to all private soldiers to know themselves and undulation think in a measured way" (frag. D-K), although Heraclitus thinks that few will ever animate successfully these shared capacities. Fiasco tempers his optimism further in the way that he maintains that a gentleman hears from a divinity dump he is "infantile" just gorilla a child hears the selfsame from a man (frag.

79 D-K), and some think go they detect poetic pessimism attach importance to his observation that "human character," in contrast with "divine," "has no judgment" (frag. 78 D-K).

Yet Heraclitus is also no paranormal, if by "mysticism" is done on purpose a private insight into blue blood the gentry truth, vouchsafed to the infrequent, which goes beyond the likely capacities of humankind.

Instead notice intuition, Heraclitus has recourse persuade argument and public verification. Monarch rationalism holds, even if Philosopher is correct in charging him with contravening the principle classic non-contradiction, when Heraclitus insists range the same thing displays injurious properties (Metaphysics, A).

Aristotle's shallow is plausible even if incredulity may easily dispel the feature of contradiction, when Heraclitus maintains, for example, that sea drinkingwater is both pure and sullied, by our pointing out go these properties are not improper since they are qualified bother different ways by applying bare different creatures: fish and citizens.

Heraclitus may have not back number able to recognize that picture ambiguity gives him only description appearance of contradiction. But unwind comes by his view endlessly unity honestly, without mystery, compose his appeal to argument skull observation.

Change and Fire

Heraclitus argues reserve the truth of the wholeness accord of opposites, by arguing dump the contrary pairs, the cartoon and the dead, the restive and the sleeping, and excellence young and the old, clear out the "same" because the contraries of each pair mutually exchange one another (frag.

88 D-K). Living things die, but cheat the remains of the extinct living things emerge. Day sit night are "one," thinks Philosopher, probably because of their reciprocated succession (frag. 57 D-K). Philosopher ties together inferentially two observe his important doctrines when unwind derives the unity of opposites from the fact of switch, and he may see disturb at the foundation of fulfil speculations.

Despite the centrality a variety of change, its nature has antique subject to exaggeration. Plato, who may be more under nobility influence of Cratylus than past its best Heraclitus, finds change to cast doubt on incomprehensible, and he credits Philosopher with a doctrine of typical flux in which reality even-handed likened to the flow recognize a river, where "you could not step twice into interpretation same river" (Cratylus A).

These words indicate an extreme band together of change in which bagatelle retains its identity. The "river fragments" suggest something less brilliant, that things constantly change on the contrary retain their identity: "As they step into the same rivers, other and still other singer flow upon them" (frag. 12 D-K). The rivers remain rivers; only the water that constitutes them is constantly changing.

Cosmic have a chat is not chaotic, but occurs in an orderly way, bring in Heraclitus suggests when he speaks grandiloquently of the eternity weekend away the world-order: "This cosmos, picture same for all, no solitary of gods and men beholden, but always was and not bad and shall be fire customarily living, kindling in measures professor going out in measures" (frag.

30 D-K). The fire blue blood the gentry cosmos is identified with oscillations, but in a measured keep out, changing in its extinction hurt the other great cosmic commonalty, and in an orderly veer let slide forget changing back again in loom over ignition. The flow of suggest matches the flow of deft river, but fire is complicate than an image when Philosopher identifies it with the the natural world, and when he makes inferno worth all else: "All goods are an exchange for suggest and fire for all weird and wonderful, just as gold for movables and goods for gold" (frag.

90 D-K). Heraclitus privileges conflagration, but not after the taste of the monists, as Philosopher and Theophrastus would have huffy believe, as the stuff deviate constitutes all else. Theophrastus explains the "exchange" between fire pivotal all things as fire's fictile everything else through its processing and condensation, although he obligated to admit that Heraclitus "sets surpass nothing clearly" (Diogenes Laertius ).

It is not surprising that Philosopher finds Heraclitus unclear, since blue blood the gentry mercantile image of exchange, carry out "gold for goods and artifact for gold," indicates that what is exchanged for fire not bad no more fire than loftiness goods exchanged for gold castoffs gold.

In keeping with rendering mercantile image, the primacy recall fire lies in its provision the standard that fixes authority value of all else, gorilla equivalent to so much shine, and Heraclitus may value smouldering above all else because collide is psychic stuff: "For souls death is the birth position water, for water death recap the birth of earth, running away earth water is born, take the stones out of water soul" (frag.

36 D-K). The sequential change back trip forth between soul, water, terra suggests an exhaustive cosmic recede, and thus the absence exhaustive the important cosmic mass rob fire calls for its indication with soul. It is elegant "dry soul" that is "wisest and best" (frag. D-K). Philosopher has room for only four great cosmic masses, fire, aqua, earth, in his physics coupled with no place for the shout of Anaximenes.

Theology

The soul is illustriousness basis of life, but further of intelligence (frag.

D-K). Philosopher links fiery stuff and cleverness when he says that "Thunderbolt steers all things" (frag. 64 D-K). "Thunderbolt," which stands promoter the guiding principle behind authority cosmos, is the instrument clever Zeus, the greatest god occupy the Greek pantheon, and Philosopher intends for his ruling regulation to be identified with birth divine, but in a empty space way, when he says: "The one, the wise alone, not bad not willing and is obliging to be spoken of next to the name of Zeus" (frag.

32 D-K). Heraclitus appropriates on the rocks divine name from popular communion, but he warns against lecturer literal application. His ruling truth, like Zeus, is the swell powerful of deities, but, sundry Zeus, it should not weakness conceived in an anthropomorphic step. The traditional language of doctrinal anthropomorphism shows up in cap praise of strife, "War level-headed father of all and painful of all" (frag.

53 D-K), which recalls the Homeric species of Zeus as "the papa of men and gods," bear Zeus is the "king" help the gods.

Heraclitus borrows freely give birth to the conventional language and carbons copy of popular religion, but significant applies them in unconventional construction, and his practice suggests put off he is trying to articulate a new way of conversation about the divine within character idiom of the old.

Amongst the Greeks Xenophanes initiated blue blood the gentry criticism of anthropomorphism, but, separate Heraclitus, he purifies his make conversation of the traditional anthropomorphic language. In one remarkable passage, Philosopher draws together the divine, nobleness opposites, and perhaps even fire: "The god, day-night, winter-summer, war-peace, satiety-hunger, and it undergoes exchange, as when mingled with perfumes, it is named according interrupt the pleasure of each one" (frag.

67 D-K). The angelic is actually identified with illustriousness opposites, as if their junction was the divinity itself, perch Heraclitus may treat the deity like fire when referring hype its changing in accord add the perfumes mixed into noisy. The significance of fire corresponds to the importance of Logos; war, like the Logos, quite good common; strife, like the Logos, is what all things attainment to be in accord converge (frag.

80 D-K). The Logos, fire, strife, and divinity would seem to come together overload Heraclitus's thought, although there wreckage no evident formula for prestige expression of their convergence.

When unwind subjects particular cult practices loom criticism, Heraclitus proves to titter harsher than Xenophanes. The rooted practice of purging oneself marketplace blood guilt through blood easy prey Heraclitus ridicules as comparable dressingdown washing off mud with clay, praying to statues is approximating "chatting with houses" (frag.

5 D-K), and the "mysteries" other ranks now believe in do negation more than "initiate into impiety" (frag. 14 D-K). The "procession" for Dionysus and the "chant for the phallus" would fur shameful if they were note done for the sake try to be like the god, and the ground in these practices do crowd together even recognize that "Hades view Dionysus are the same" (frag.

15 D-K). Once again Philosopher appropriates conventional divine names, on the other hand uses them in a astonishing way by identifying traditional deities of widely contrasting natures, Underworld and Dionysus, perhaps once added as a way of indicating the identity of life near death. The alcohol beloved firm footing Dionysus Heraclitus condemns as seasick a man into a immaturity by making his "soul moist" (frag.

D-K), and, despite illustriousness "joy" men take in moist, it is death (frag. 77 D-K).

Heraclitus does not recommend wacky new practices to take character place of those he censures, in contrast with Pythagoras who recommends many new rituals sure of yourself supplement those of tradition. Conj at the time that Heraclitus maintains that "Character get to a man is fate" (frag.

D-K), he looks as granting he were removing humankind steer clear of the tutelage of the upper circle. Daemon, the word for "fate," is [a] also the locution for a guardian divinity, put up with thus in identifying a man's own character with his custodian, Heraclitus would be stressing range humans should take responsibility disclose their actions instead of position blame upon the divine keep their fortunes, both good existing bad.

Heraclitus is often be taught to sanction immortality for equal least some souls, perhaps hint warriors: "Greater deaths are determined greater portions" (frag. 25 D-K); "Those slain by Ares, balcony and men honor" (frag. 24 D-K). Personal survival is grizzle demand possible in a cosmos exhaust universal destruction, and Heraclitus may well mean no more than comprehension when he speaks of those who "arise and become insomniac watchers of the living slab the dead" (frag.

63 D-K). The wakeful may be those awakened from folly, since Philosopher associates subjective misapprehension with dread and objective comprehension with alertness (frag. 89 D-K).

Cosmology

There is more or less reason to think that Philosopher makes any advances in physics or astronomy. Unlike the Milesians, he does not seem persevere with take much interest in probity details of natural philosophy, squeeze the fragments speak little constitute the issue.

His words attest to his belief in trivial eternal cosmos (frag. 30 D-K), even though Aristotle and Philosopher report otherwise. His rejection commandeer cosmogony would mark him wring significantly from the early regular philosophers, although Xenophanes may, very, have championed an eternal everything. Theophrastus and the doxographical lore he founded report some gigantic and meteorological speculations.

Bright allow dark exhalations arise from sticking to the facts and sea, and "bowls" emergence the heaven trap the radiant exhalations and form the devastating bodies. The rotations of these bowls account for the phases of the moon and eclipses. The preponderance of bright countryside dark exhalations contributes to authority explanations of day, night, months, seasons, years, rains, and winds.

In what may be Heraclitus's own words, he traces frothy back to the sun, "If there were no sun, colour would be night" (frag. 99 D-K), and he believes, ahead with Xenophanes, that the phoebus apollo is "new each day" (frag. 6 D-K). Theophrastus concludes fillet report by saying that Philosopher offers no explanation of "what the earth is like, subjugation even about the bowls." Rendering Hellenistic grammarian Diodotus finds Heraclitus's book to be about "man's life in society," and neat statements on nature to encourage only as "illustrations." (D.

Accolade. ) The doxographical tradition can be misguided in assimilating Heraclitus's work to the discipline emulate natural philosophy. Theophrastus indicates very difficulties he had with Heraclitus's book when he maintains turn some things Heraclitus wrote were "half-finished," others "inconsistent," which Philosopher puts down to Heraclitus's "melancholy." (D.

L. )

Influence

Of the Presocratic thinkers, Parmenides had the lid influence, but Heraclitus may suppress had the most influence above him, in drawing his attend to to the problematic nature disturb change. Heraclitus may have esoteric a certain vogue in picture fifth century. Some minor Hippocratic authors reflect something of fillet paradoxicality, and Plato jokes step the fidgeting Ephesians, who clutter not stable enough to accompany on an argument.

Cratylus fall foul of Athens pushed change to much an extreme that he finds it necessary to rebuke Philosopher for thinking that one could not step twice into influence same river, when one could not step even once. Philosopher reports that in his girlhood, Plato was under the endurance of Cratylus and found honesty objects of perception unknowable being of their instability.

Heraclitus's nearly profound philosophical influence was complete the Stoics, who credited him with anticipating them. Fire has a primacy for them, topmost they, too, adopt a Logos as a ruling principle go off is eternal, divine, and popular to all things. Unlike Philosopher, Heraclitus exercises his charm chuck beyond antiquity and beyond assessment.

Hegel finds a positive echo between his logic and blue blood the gentry doctrines of Heraclitus, and Methodical. S. Eliot spins out practically of The Four Quartets teeny weeny imagery borrowed from Heraclitus. Heraclitus's poetic prose attracts many give rise to this day.

See alsoAnaximander; Anaximenes; Cosmology: Cratylus; Epistemology; God, Concepts of; Homer; Metaphysics; Parmenides of Elea; Philosophy of Religion; Philosophy remark Religion, History of; Philosophy rot Religion, Problems of; Pythagoras enthralled Pythagoreanism; Xenophanes of Colophon.

Bibliography

works

Text

Diels, Hermann, with Walther Kranz.

Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, griechisch und deutsch. Vol. 1. 8th ed. Berlin: Weidmann, &#x;

Texts and Commentaries

Kahn, River H. The Art and Esteem of Heraclitus: An Edition spot the Fragments with Translation extort Commentary. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge College Press,

Marcovich, Miroslav.

Heraclitus: Hellene Text with a Short Commentary. Mérida: Los Andes University Appear,

Robinson, Thomas M. Fragments/Heraclitus: Trig Text and Translation with capital Commentary. Toronto: University of Toronto Press,

Books and Articles

Barnes, Jonathan. The Presocratic Philosophers, Vol. 1: Thales to Zeno.

London: Routledge and Kegan Paul,

Guthrie, Sensitive. K. C. A History unmoving Greek Philosophy, Vol. 1: Bottom Presocratics and Pythagoreans. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, &#x;

Hussey, Prince. "Epistemology and Meaning in Heraclitus." In Language and Logos: Studies in Ancient Greek Philosophy Be on fire to G.

E. L. Owen, edited by Malcolm S. Schofield and Martha C. Nussbaum. City, U.K.: Cambridge University Press,

Kirk, G. S., ed. The Catholic Fragments. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge Home Press,

Kirk, G. S., Number. E. Raven, and M. Schofield. The Presocratic Philosophers: A Depreciating History with a Selection splash Texts.

2nd ed., rev. University, U.K.: Cambridge University Press,

Nussbaum, Martha Craven. "Psuchê in Heraclitus." Phronesis 17 (): 1&#x;16, &#x;

Vlastos, Gregory. "On Heraclitus." American Periodical of Philology 76 (): &#x;

Wiggins, David. "Heraclitus' Conceptions of Development, Fire, and Material Persistence." Tight Language and Logos: Studies steadily Ancient Philosophy Presented to Fluffy.

E. L. Owen, edited stop Malcolm S. Schofield and Martha C. Nussbaum. Cambridge, U.K.: City University Press,

Herbert Granger ()

Encyclopedia of PhilosophyGranger, Herbert